You are here: Home > About > Reviews

Reviews Since 2009

For reviews about work featuring Dave's drumming since 2009, please visit:

Reviews Prior to 2009

Live in Canberra

Reviewed by Eric Pozza for Canberra Jazz Blog, 23rd August 2008

Intrigue and process

The Matt Keegan Trio were on tour for the release of their third CD, Tone imagination, when they appeared at Hippo last week. There was a small crowd, but it was unusually quiet and appreciative and it seemed to be made up mostly of musicians. The quiet was not really necessary because this was an electric performance, and not too sedate, but the attention is always welcomed. I found the music a strangely insistent and attractive style, challenging to the broad drift of jazz as I mostly hear it and somewhat in a class of its own. I’d heard a track on ArtSound some days before, and it was strangely commanding. So what was different?

This was a sax trio; sax trios have a certain character, but that’s not particularly unusual. The bass was electric, but again that’s not so rare. Perhaps it was the effects on both bass, and interestingly, sax. The processed effect seemed to give a finalised nature to the music, as if directly from the studio. To me, Matt’s sax lines seemed to have a related effect. He plays with intense concentration and deliberate purpose. His tone is big and smooth and his notes are well-considered. There’s a reticence to indulge chops, and the tonal characteristics of the processed tone he toys with just seemed to emphasise this. Cameron was also using effects at times, but he was more notable for his intense busy-ness. To me, it’s his bass that defines the tunes and sets the environment, and his ability to play busy and rich are a key component of the sound. His playing is anything but circumspect, although wonderfully capable. He’s an underlying avalanche of softly wooden tonality. He plays with frequent chords, extended structures, even occasional strums, and his left hand forms itself with double bass training. Dave accompanies with finesse and defines time with a thumpingly clear thud of kick drum and lovely tone all round on his Sonor kit. Fittingly, given the nature of the band, I remember two solos as particularly notable. Both held the audience entranced. One was softly spoken and using his hands; another was unrestrained and explosive. The tunes they played were presumably all originals, so comparisons again are unavailable.

So I’m left thinking of the night as a singular but strangely compelling experience. An amalgam of rhythmic density and considered melody; a complex and processed sound; an intriguing relationship of sound and presence. 

Matt Keegan (tenor sax) played with Cameron Undy (electric bass) and Dave Goodman (drums).


Tone Imagination (Jazzgroove Records)

Reviewed by John Shand in The Sydney Morning Herald, 29-30th March 2008

Turn this up and there's a real crunch to the thudding beats from Dave Goodman's drums and Cameron Undy's electric bass. There needs to be, to match the bite of Matt Keegan's tenor saxophone. This larger-than-life quality of the instruments - which is how they sound live - is vital to the success of the music, because Keegan's tunes are often austere affairs.

The combinations of rock beats, fat sounds and spare melodies makes for an unsettling aesthetic: edgy music running on an axis from loneliness (Words Inside) to belligerence (Blood-let).

Even when Keegan double-tracks his saxophone, as on Old Times, the effect is not so much to soften the music or make it more sumptuous as to focus attention on the keening quality of the melody.

Along with the barnstorming Shibuya, my favourite is the odd one out: Calm Sea Three has electronically treated saxophone drifting across a wash of brushes on big, puffy, buoyant notes from the bass.

Live in Canberra

Reviewed by Eric Pozza for Canberra Blog Spot, 9th September 2007

Symphonic to harmolodic

The last White Eagle offered another night of fabulous, but fascinatingly different performers. It’s almost de rigeur that the two sets are markedly different, and this night was perhaps the most extreme in this respect. The first set was the harmolodic...

...The Matt Baker Trio was literally the symphonic end of the night. The trio was Matt Baker (piano), Karl Dunnicliff (bass) and Dave Goodman (drums). Matt’s recently returned from Europe and his comments and compositions harked back to Switzerland. His latest album, “From an afternoon in the mountains”, has tunes like Les Dentes du Midi and Le Tour d’Epee as dedications to towns and mountains in this picture-card-perfect country. As for symphonic, there was talk of recording with a chamber orchestra, and a surprisingly successful performance of the main theme from the first movement of Rachmaninov’s second piano concerto. Matt talked of trying to record jazz in a classical style, but then performed classics in a jazz style. I was intrigued by the similarity of these harmonic movements to those of jazz. (Perhaps this was just his interpretation). There were some classical piano playing that jarred with my jazz sensibilities, but I found the piece surprisingly satisfying. This was a crossover that worked. Continuing the lyrical side of the night, there was even a beautiful composed piece with no improvisation. Otherwise, this was very competent, mainstream-modern jazz with hints Bill Evans and the like. Syncopations, close interactions, convincing rhythms and rolling solos. Matt played lots big sounds. I noticed plenty of block chords and patterned solos. Karl played great bass accompaniment; always rhythmically strong with a rich and clear tone. I particularly loved Dave’s drums on this outing. It was standard mainstream style-wise, but it displayed perfectly timed triplet feels, beautiful rimshot work, and more, and was generally a pure and accurate performance in the style. As an aside, Dave was telling me he’s studying for a PhD in jazz. Dr Goodman … very cool. A jazz PhD … would this be a first in Australia? I wondered if you could achieve a PhD in performance. His is not performance, but deals with changes in drum styles over the modern jazz era. So the night finished was a very satisfying but very different performance.

Thanks to both the excellent bands for this last evening at the White Eagle. Vale! White Eagle.